Seeing-Beyond
A couple weeks ago, I had my students write a rhetorical analysis. This is one of the hardest assignments that I give my students and many of them struggled with it. One girl, however, made an unexpected, life-changing, discovery.
For her analysis, she reviewed the lyrics of one of her favorite songs. Up to that point she had thought the song was about suicide and she had planned to write about that, but as she looked at the lyrics again and considered the timeframe of when it was written, she suddenly realized that it wasn't talking about suicide at all, it was talking about 9/11.
This discovery opened a whole new world for her. Excitedly, she told me, "I never thought about looking for that sort of thing before, but now I see it everywhere! There is a lot more out there than I thought."
I gave her my best "wise professor look" and sagely observed: "It's a whole new world, isn't it?" She nodded vigerously.
Her experience reminded me of a line in The Giver by Lois Lowry. In that story, the main character is chosen to be the "Receiver of Memories" because of his ability to "See-Beyond." In the context of the book, it means that he can see color which most other citizens of the novel--by choice or lack of knowledge--can't.
For me, that is what rhetorical analysis is like--it is "Seeing-Beyond" the public fascade to the worlds that exists just out of sight. It is discovering a world of treasures hidden to anyone who doesn't choose to seek them, doesn't think they are important, or doesn't want to break through their own persoanl boundaries of perception.
It reminds me of the "feed the birds" scene in Mary Poppins. In that scene, The children, excited for their upcoming outing with their father, exclaim, "We'll see all the sights, and father can point them out to us." Gently, Mary Poppins corrects them, "Well, most things he can. But sometimes a person we love, through no fault of his own, can't see past the end of his nose."
The sad part for me is that this inability to "see past the end of [our noses]" is self-inflicted, or at least society-inflicted. We have established ways of perceiving the world and most aren't willing to even try a new way. In the immortal words of Horton the Elephant from Seussical the Musical:
There are secrets on a leaf,
In the water, in the air,
Hidden planets, tiny worlds
All invisible!
Not a person seems to know.
Not a person seems to care.
There is no one who believes a thing I say...
Well, I'm fairly certain
At one time or other,
Great thinkers all feel this way!
I often wonder how much we miss because we don't open our eyes and "See-Beyond." How many worlds have gone undiscovered because we wrote the whole task of discovery off as unimportant or too difficult or didn't even notice the possibility for discovery in the first place?
And then I think of what it feels like to find those worlds, the rush of discovering that past your limited view lay a whole, undiscovered country. And it makes me want to look even more.
Again, I think Horton describes it best:
Yes, I have wings.
And I can fly
Around the moon
And far beyond the sky.
I jsut wish the rest of my students could feel that as well.