It is funny how, as your kids get older, you begin to understand the pain that you put your parents through. This week brought that into sharp focus when the kids brought home their report cards.
For the most part, the report cards were very good, but Joey is failing in one, very important area. It brought back a very bitter memory of my own time in elementary school and I suddenly understood things that didn't entirely make sense to me at the time.
It happened when I was in sixth grade—the year I pretty much wrote off school. That year my teacher was... how to say this politely... not the best for me. He made it too easy for me to skip assignments and space out in class. I'm not blaming him for how I acted that year or for my grades, I'm just saying that his easy-going, hands-off teaching style just made my bad attitude about school worse.
That year I missed a lot of assignments. I think it was somewhere around half in some subject areas that I thought were stupid. My grades, which, until 5th grade, had been pretty good, dropped dramatically. But until 6th grade I'd always managed to pull off mostly Bs and Cs with the minimal effort I put into my school work. In 6th grade, I all but stopped trying and my grades slipped to Cs and Ds.
I honestly don't remember learning anything that year. I remember winning a writing competition and going to NAU to meet a real author (a highlight of my youth), but I don't remember a single thing I learned beyond that. I do, however, remember some of the stupid things I did to avoid having to think about certain subjects. Health was my worst subject. Not because I didn't understand it, but because I thought it was stupid and pointless. I went to extraordinary lengths to avoid thinking about health, including using the bubble sheets for our health quizzes to make fun patterns like zigzags and circles and things. I also remember not wanting to "waste" my time on the subject so rushing through assignments like answering "True, False, True, False, True, False" rather than even reading the questions.
Needless to say, my attitude came out in my grades and the fateful day when I got my first (and only) "F" arrived.
I knew that it was coming and that there wasn't anything I could do about it. So a few days before report cards came out, I asked my mom what she would do if I brought home an "F" on my report card. Her answer surprised me.
"I'll probably cry," she said. "And then... I don't know."
And that is exactly what happened. When I gave her my card, she didn't say anything— much worse than if she'd yelled. She just went into her room and cried for what seemed like a very long time. I felt terrible.
At the time, I really didn't understand why she was crying. After all, it was MY grade and MY fault. What did it have to do with her? Somehow I felt that it was unfair.
On Monday, I finally understood.
When Joey brought home his report card with the failing grade, it made me sick. The thing is, I wasn't upset at him so much as upset at myself. I knew that he bore some of the fault, but I felt like it was more my fault. I felt like I had failed him in some way. It made me feel terrible and, like my mother, I cried.
I suddenly understood what I never could as a child. As parents we care so much about our kids. Right or wrong, we hold ourselves responsible for their success and failure. When they succeed, we are happy. When they fail, we feel it almost more than they do.
I think that the key is that we, as parents, are better equipped to see the long-term effects of their actions. Also, we can see ourselves in them, so we feel it more.
Oddly enough, it made me think of a Simpsons episode. In the episode, Bart does something bad (can't remember what) and Homer punishes him by refusing to let Bart go to the new Itchy & Scratchy movie. It is the first time Homer has ever punished Bart and made it stick. Always before he gave in after Bart put on the miserable act. This time is different because Homer is haunted by the thought that Bart could end up as a criminal or a Supreme Court Justice depending on whether Homer punishes him or not. So, no matter how hard Bart tries to get Homer to change his mind, Homer sticks with his guns.
The episode ends several years later with Homer and Bart—now a Supreme Court Justice thanks to Homer's one moment of parenting—walking along the streets of Springfield. They see that the movie theater is playing the Itchy & Scratchy film. Now that Bart has grown into a great man, they agree to see it together. When Itchy (the mouse) does something mean to Scratchy that, to some degree, mirrors the terrible act that Bart did earlier, Homer comments that "Itchy is a jerk." Bart laughs and puts his arm around his dad's shoulders. "Yes he is," he says.
Okay, not exactly related to Joey's issue, but as a father, I can relate to Homer's dilemma. He felt responsible—COMPLETELY responsible—for how Bart turned out in the future. Bart's future happiness pivoted solely on whether or not Homer could actually punish him and therefore teach him the consequences of bad behavior.
I think that the fact that Homer's one moment of parenting really did have the desired impact on his son is both a parent's greatest dream and worst nightmare. We love the idea that we can make such a difference in the lives of our children, but it is terrifying to think that we may screw them up beyond repair.
That was how I felt about Joey. I felt like his failure was actually mine. That I was a bad parent because I hadn't taught him correctly. Whether that was true or not didn't matter. I am his father, he is my responsibility and as a result I will always feel that what he does says just as much about me as it does about him.
It made me understand how my mother felt. I suddenly understood why my "F" caused her to cry. She felt like she had failed—that she hadn't been the mother she should have been.
Today, I can honestly tell her that it wasn't her fault. It was all mine. And I am very sorry I made her feel that way.
I can only hope that we can reach Joey like she reached me. Maybe he'll wind up as a Supreme Court Justice.